Challenging The Institution of Sport and Its Values: The Costs and Benefits of Female Athletes in M :: Film Films Movies Sports Women Essays

Challenging The Institution of Sport and Its ValuesSport is non an expression of some biological human need, writes Michael Messner, it is a neighborly institution. Like other institutions, such as the economy, politics, and the family, the building and values of shimmer emerge and change historically, largely as a result of struggles for power between groups of people (8). Indeed, changing the structure of any the institution is a struggle that is not by any means easily won. The institution of sport presents a unique set of boundaries to belabor with regard to gender equality in masculine-henpecked sports. Both men and women take big risks when they forge new ground by competing in a sport that is traditionally dominated by the opposite sex. This paper will discuss the costs and benefits of women competing in predominately male-dominated sports by examining Karyn Kusamas Girlfight and Pumping Iron II The Women. In Karyn Kusamas Girlfight (2000), Diana Guzman is a uncompromi sing spring chicken woman, struggling to get by in a low-income area of the Brooklyn. After continued disciplinary problems in school, Diana conduct her aggression into draw a bead oning to engender a boxer. She fights to assert herself both inside and outside of the boxing ring inside the ring, she proves that she is a strong and athletically talented young (woman) boxer outside of the ring, she fights to secure and prove herself in a broken home. After proving her strength when she defended her brother Tiny in a sparring pinch at the gym, Diana asks Hector to train her to become a boxer. Hector replies, You can train, but you cant compete...you just cant. Girls dont have the same power as boys. Hectors response, and the response of approximately of the men in her invigoration is indicative of the function and effect of power in the institution of sport. Michael Messner arguesThe structure and values of sport are largely do by, and in the interests of, those who hold power ...power is not simply a top-down, one-way process in which dominant groups assert and enforce their rules, values, and beliefs over dominated groups. Rather, power is a process in which dominated groups may partially accept, but also attempt to redefine, negotiate, or even reject, the ruling groups rules, values, and meanings (12). Diana proves to Hector, and her competitors, that her strength and athleticism are not only comparable to her male counterparts, but often far exceeds them.Challenging The Institution of Sport and Its Values The Costs and Benefits of Female Athletes in M mental picture Films Movies Sports Women EssaysChallenging The Institution of Sport and Its ValuesSport is not an expression of some biological human need, writes Michael Messner, it is a social institution. Like other institutions, such as the economy, politics, and the family, the structure and values of sport emerge and change historically, largely as a result of struggles for power between groups of people (8). Indeed, changing the structure of any the institution is a struggle that is not by any means easily won. The institution of sport presents a unique set of boundaries to overcome with regard to gender equality in male-dominated sports. Both men and women take big risks when they forge new ground by competing in a sport that is traditionally dominated by the opposite sex. This paper will discuss the costs and benefits of women competing in predominately male-dominated sports by examining Karyn Kusamas Girlfight and Pumping Iron II The Women. In Karyn Kusamas Girlfight (2000), Diana Guzman is a tough young woman, struggling to get by in a low-income area of the Brooklyn. After continued disciplinary problems in school, Diana channels her aggression into training to become a boxer. She fights to assert herself both inside and outside of the boxing ring inside the ring, she proves that she is a strong and athletically talented young (woman) boxer outside of the ring, she fights to define and prove herself in a broken home. After proving her strength when she defended her brother Tiny in a sparring match at the gym, Diana asks Hector to train her to become a boxer. Hector replies, You can train, but you cant compete...you just cant. Girls dont have the same power as boys. Hectors response, and the response of most of the men in her life is indicative of the function and effect of power in the institution of sport. Michael Messner arguesThe structure and values of sport are largely shaped by, and in the interests of, those who hold power...power is not simply a top-down, one-way process in which dominant groups assert and enforce their rules, values, and beliefs over dominated groups. Rather, power is a process in which dominated groups may partially accept, but also attempt to redefine, negotiate, or even reject, the ruling groups rules, values, and meanings (12). Diana proves to Hector, and her competitors, that her strength and athleticism are not only comparable to her male counterparts, but often far exceeds them.